Which Gas Logs Are the Right Size for Me?
Now that you've gone through the steps of making the really broad decisions in selecting your gas logs, it's time to get a little more specific. This is the point at which most gas log shoppers begin narrowing down the vast selections of ventless or vented gas logs based on things like fireplace size considerations, types of controls, pilot systems vs. manual gas valves, and others. On this page, we'll take a look at each of the factors that can really make a difference in choosing the right gas logs.
If you're going with ventless gas logs that come in their own cabinet you don't have to worry too much about the size. For the rest of you, though, selecting a set of gas logs that you like and that fits properly within your fireplace is a must. You can simply use the handy-dandy gas log calculator located here on eFireplaceStore.com, but let's run through some basic size considerations so you know exactly what you're looking for.
Gas Log Sizing Factors
- Relevant fireplace dimensions for choosing gas logs include the width of the front opening of the fireplace, the width of the rear fireplace wall, the height of the front fireplace opening, and the fireplace depth from front opening to rear wall
- A minimum of 2 inches on both sides must be maintained between the gas log burner system equipment and the fireplace sidewalls, and some customers prefer up to 6 inches on both sides
- The gas log set chosen should not be longer than the width of the rear fireplace wall
- Fireplace should be a minimum of 12 to 14 inches deep for almost any kind of gas logs
- Don't forget — when selecting gas log sizes based on the burner system equipment, you MUST allow room for the fuel control system your gas log burner uses (for more information, refer to the Quick Reference section below)
- We'll discuss each in detail in the next section, but for the purposes of choosing gas logs the three basic types of fuel control systems to consider are Manual on/off gas valves, Manual safety pilot valves, and Millivolt or remote-ready pilot valves
- Choosing a gas log set that is too large for the fireplace can affect the burn and hamper the operation of the fuel control system
- Choosing a gas log set that is too small can diminish the beauty of the hearth setting
- Selecting a gas log set that is either too large or too small can adversely affect proper fireplace drafting
Types of Fuel Control Systems
As promised, here's where we take a closer look at the three main types of gas log fuel control systems. Check them out to see how each works and which system appeals to you, then we'll wrap this page up with a quick look at the sizing implications of each system.
Manual On/Off Valve
This is the simplest type of fuel control system, the one many of us used in years past. You turn a manual on/off valve open and closed by hand, light the gas log burner with a match, and adjust the flame height via the valve by hand, as well.
- Easy to operate
- Least expensive fuel control system
- Uses the least amount of space in the fireplace
- Manual valves are NOT ALLOWED for use with liquid propane
- Manual valves are not used with ventless gas logs
- Potentially hazardous as a child can possibly open the valve, releasing raw gas into the home
Manual Safety Pilot Valve
This fuel control system is similar to that used on a furnace or water heater. There are 'Off', 'Pilot', and 'On' positions. Initially you have to turn the valve to the 'Pilot' position and light the pilot with a match, but after that you can turn the gas logs on and off by switching between the 'On' and 'Pilot' positions. The pilot will stay lit until turned to 'Off' or blown out, at which point it automatically shuts off gas flow. Propane gas logs require a safety pilot valve of some kind.
- Still relatively simple to operate
- Can be turned off in the summer months to save fuel
- Still requires manual lighting of the pilot flame
- Somewhat limited flame control in the 'On' position
- More expensive than manual on/off valve to purchase
- Uses slightly more fireplace space than a manual on/off valve
Millivolt (Remote-ready) Pilot Valve
This is very similar to a manual safety pilot valve, except a remote-ready pilot valve can be connected to an optional device to remotely turn the gas on or off or control the flame height. These devices range from inexpensive remotes or wall switches designed only to turn the gas on and off to more expensive remotes that can adjust flame heights and set timers, or even thermostats that will turn the flame down once the desired temperature is reached.
- Remote operation, requiring no manual lighting of the pilot
- Maximum user flexibility
- Allows for many devices, some of which can be changed as needs change
- Most expensive fuel control system
- Takes up the most space in the fireplace of any fuel control system
Some final tips to give you an idea about how each gas log fuel control system affects the size gas log set you need. This reference is somewhat general and some gas log sets may have individual space requirements, so read the information about individual gas log sets carefully!
Manual On/Off Valve
No pilot kit is involved, so all you need is 2 inches of clearance between the burner system and the fireplace on each side. Measure the fireplace's front opening width, subtract 4 inches, and the resulting length is the largest size gas log set your fireplace can accommodate.
Manual Safety Pilot Valve
The safety pilot valve occupies some space, so again measure the front opening width of the fireplace, but subtract 8 total inches rather than the 4 inches required for the manual on/off valve. The resulting measurement is the largest gas log set equipped with a manual safety pilot valve your fireplace can handle.
Remote-ready Pilot Valve
This is about the same as the manual safety pilot valve calculation, but in this case subtract 12 inches from the opening width to find the largest gas log set equipped with a remote-ready pilot valve suitable for your fireplace.